First try?!?! Beginners luck still exists i guess lmao looks really good!
Saneless
What kind of pep is that?
SolidMikeP
First try? DAMN YOU GOT THE TOUCH
Pizza_Casalinga
Right. Cause I put my first try pizza into a legit pizza box and had all this.
bigboxes1
First try at what? You’re lifting it out of a to-go box and then grating cheese on a finished pizza. What exactly did you do for the first time?
Equivalent-Emu5347
Sure dude lol
loomdog1
Just the cupping on the pepperoni is proof you are not a first timer.
CutiePopIceberg

Desperate_Passage_35
I like a little black pepper on my pepperoni. Looks amazing.
zevans08
How you cook this?
BunnyPrincess__
Looks terrible. I’ll come over and get that from you for safe disposal. 👀
DankDogeDude69
What did you use to cook it?
Muppet83
Nice looking pizza. But first try? Yeeeeah….

therealvelvetworm
What’s the benefit of putting a home made pizza in a pizza box?
Shanbo88
Pretty good for a first time posting. Maybe try posting your own pizza next time though.
122_Hours_Of_Fear
This is like when someone posts a perfect boule or loaf in r/breadit saying it’s their first time*.
*Has experience with dough and cooking in general, so while it’s true it’s their first time, it’s a bit disingenuous. Like, they’ve baked before but never made that specific thing, so it’s their first time, *technically*.
NeverSayDie00
That thing looks killer. I want a slice.
HI_DUMDUM_
looks amazing, but what kinda moron makes a pizza and then puts it in a takeout pizza box? can you see why people dont believe you?
agr85
That’s a fuckin pizza 🍕
Easy_Most_9029
First try? Naaaah
jbiroliro
You know you did well
The_Time_Lord
You’d be a great server at my restaurant concept — Mostly Parmesan. We only menu things that you put parm on and all the wait staff hand cranks parm onto EVERYTHING and anything the customer wants.
Anyhow, nice pie.
Random_Monstrosities
Good enough for me to try to eat it all in one sitting
DarkGraphite
Show me the bottom!
Eat_Ya_Food_Son
Maaaaaan lemme get two slices maynneeee
Ok-Estate8230
Don’t care if you’re a baker. Baking is science and pizza is a passion. If this is in fact your first attempt at making pizza then bravo my man. This thing is absolutely beautiful and cooked perfectly Michaelangelo.
33 Comments
Where these peps from?!
gtfoh 😂
First try?!?! Beginners luck still exists i guess lmao looks really good!
What kind of pep is that?
First try? DAMN YOU GOT THE TOUCH
Right. Cause I put my first try pizza into a legit pizza box and had all this.
First try at what? You’re lifting it out of a to-go box and then grating cheese on a finished pizza. What exactly did you do for the first time?
Sure dude lol
Just the cupping on the pepperoni is proof you are not a first timer.

I like a little black pepper on my pepperoni. Looks amazing.
How you cook this?
Looks terrible. I’ll come over and get that from you for safe disposal. 👀
What did you use to cook it?
Nice looking pizza. But first try? Yeeeeah….

What’s the benefit of putting a home made pizza in a pizza box?
Pretty good for a first time posting. Maybe try posting your own pizza next time though.
This is like when someone posts a perfect boule or loaf in r/breadit saying it’s their first time*.
*Has experience with dough and cooking in general, so while it’s true it’s their first time, it’s a bit disingenuous. Like, they’ve baked before but never made that specific thing, so it’s their first time, *technically*.
That thing looks killer. I want a slice.
looks amazing, but what kinda moron makes a pizza and then puts it in a takeout pizza box? can you see why people dont believe you?
That’s a fuckin pizza 🍕
First try? Naaaah
You know you did well
You’d be a great server at my restaurant concept — Mostly Parmesan. We only menu things that you put parm on and all the wait staff hand cranks parm onto EVERYTHING and anything the customer wants.
Anyhow, nice pie.
Good enough for me to try to eat it all in one sitting
Show me the bottom!
Maaaaaan lemme get two slices maynneeee
Don’t care if you’re a baker. Baking is science and pizza is a passion. If this is in fact your first attempt at making pizza then bravo my man. This thing is absolutely beautiful and cooked perfectly Michaelangelo.
That looks awesome!
https://preview.redd.it/ndsba4ltnlrf1.jpeg?width=3024&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=24c76203fe15b9e1f6a276c190fe92b5175cf9a0
This was the flour I used
https://preview.redd.it/92t5s4ivnlrf1.jpeg?width=3024&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=599a996c23d1e16e7bdff48a195dc7614b7b58be
This is the mixer I used and standing right next to it is a poolish. In the background is a empty pizza box
https://preview.redd.it/nh2t1q50olrf1.jpeg?width=3024&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=1876d7efe6755d24586760391d43ab14f4fdacbc
This is my Super smooth dough
https://preview.redd.it/4m9qzzv1olrf1.jpeg?width=4032&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=44beda23478e3e68a7c270c5d4ba818dcafa70ac
This is me putting the dough up to proof for 24 hours